My Love/Hate Affair with Research

I came up against the great Research problem yesterday. It doesn’t matter if I’m writing fantasy, historical fiction, westerns, or like now science fiction, eventually I always come up against that wall where I know something but not enough, or even that I know nothing at all. That means taking the time, and I rarely have enough of that nowadays, to do a little digging. But even if I groan with frustration at my lack of complete and instant knowledge of everything and anything, in the end I always cave in and do the leg work.

In order to create believable fictional worlds (that are not entirely self-indulgent) it is essential to get the facts right – or at least plausible.

I was having a discussion with a friend just the other day about terrible movies (I was loathing Sweeny Todd because of the Stephen Sodenhiem score, amongst other things) and he started mocking The Lady in the Water. One of his major beefs with the movie was the scene where Paul Giametti spends ten minutes underwater swimming around without needing to breathe. Now this scene really really pisses him off. He was quite vocal, maybe even for ten minutes about how ludicrous this is. Now you need to remember or be aware (if you haven’t seen the movie) that the premise of The Lady in the Water is fantasy. She’s some otherworld creature that’s been stranded and there are monsters trying to get her.

None of this bothers my friend – and it shouldn’t. What bothers him is the character of an ordinary human guy swimming around and around not needing to breathe with nary a sound byte of explanation. It broke the believability and took him out of the magic. Ok, potential magic, because we are talking about The Lady in the Water here which has far more flaws than a few logical discrepancies. It broke the rhythm and ripped dear viewer out of the illusion the movie makers were trying to create. By comparison it all became silly. That is what you really don’t want to do when you writing fiction.

They say “write what you know” and that’s a bit misunderstood at times. Obviously you can’t just write what you know experientially in this life or we wouldn’t have Jules Verne or J.R.R. Tolkien. Verne never went to the moon and Tolkien probably never met an elf, but in either case these writers went to great lengths to create something believable for their readers. Verne may seem dated now but to his Victorian readers his science seemed magical but perhaps plausible in a world that was rapidly changing faster than it ever had before, and with that he was able to draw them along into imagining the fantasy, strongly enough that people still enjoy reading Verne today. Tolkien went even further. It wasn’t just the magic of his words and the consistency of his vision, but the amount of erudition he added to it, from his creation of new languages as a master of linguistics to his knowledge of the folklore of Europe. In the background of his own stories were copious amounts of back-story crafted from his imagination wedded to existing traditions.

Yesterday, for my latest vision, a science fiction story set not to far in the future that asks what happens if we were plunged into a nuclear winter for twenty or so years, had me spending two hours reading about the Coldstream Guards so that I could create a believable character who is a Lt. Colonel in the Coldstream in this grim London landscape that I and my fellow collaborative writers are working on. If I just fudged it, using my limited knowledge of the British military, at least one of my fellow writers (British of course!) would find my stories to be unbelievable. Lord knows how many potential readers I would put off and alienate. I might never use more than ten percent of what I have read about the Coldstream Guards, but the important thing is that I know what my character would or would not do, what rank is reasonable, whether it was likely that Coldstream Guards would have survived as a regiment, etc.

There is no single story I can think of that I have ever written where I haven’t had to dip into at least a smidgeon of research. Even for contemporary stories I need to research law, forensics, the cultures of other ethnic groups from my own, or how to site a good well. My most casual story will include me look up medical facts, how a hospital runs, or even how long it takes for a person to die of thirst.

It is all in the details.

Advertisements

About panhistoria

writer, online community creator, and artist View all posts by panhistoria

4 responses to “My Love/Hate Affair with Research

  • Joel Heffner

    Your post reminds me of the similarities between fiction and non-fiction. We all must do research, outline, edit…and hope for the best.

  • Hatshepsut

    I can’t think of any story where I didn’t do significant research in order to better understand what I was attempting to portray and utilize the information available. Even when I’m working solely in the confines of an insular tale I generally end up looking for a bit of realistic perspective to enhance my fiction.

    I do find that we often research into other works of fiction for references ironic. Fiction itself becomes a resource from which to build. Does that add to the foundation of realism?

    And don’t think I missed your particular wording about Tolkien… *Grin*

  • Carly Tuma

    I’ve been tossing around a vaguely similar idea (no nuclear winter on my end, just a devastated government trying to regain control of the masses) and I’ve never been much of a researcher. I guess I just never know quite where to start, and I end up scattered all over the place with ten thousand tabs open in my browser, trying to take it all in at once.

    If you have any suggestions for researching effectively, I would be very happy to have them. 🙂

  • panhistoria

    Where I would start, if it was my story, is by understanding the workings of the government. A college textbook might even be handy – but without knowing more specifically I can’t say with certainty.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: